Replace Zuni rockets and other large rockets warhead from Heat to HE/SAP

Currently, rockets like Zuni with Heat warheads are not work well anymore; the overpressure almost does not exist. Direct hits on armored targets will only kill 1/2 crew members; even some LT are able to survive from that due to HEAT (no overpressure), these rockets need to replace the warhead to HE, which exists in real life MK24/63; just replace it as HE/SAP) which is like S13OF in the game

https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/OuzSgqKRxmb1

As i understand it there were no changes to the rockets but rather a correction to what modules in the vehicles cause overpressure since there were some modules that did cause it when they shouldn’t have.

( Community Bug Reporting System )

( Community Bug Reporting System )

On top of that people tend to misunderstand how overpressure works on HEAT rounds in general. The pressure part of the explosion doesn’t really travel in the “forward” direction as the energy of the explosion in that direction goes into forming the beam of copper. The part that causes overpressure is to a majority traveling to the “sides” of the direction of travel of the munition.

As an example:

First shot doesn’t overpressure since the pressure wave travels along the roof instead of into it while in the second shot the pressure wave travels into (and through) the roof and overpressures the vehicle.

For more info in general on the overpressure mechanic you can read more here: ( The Mechanics of High-Explosive Effect and Overpressure | War Thunder Wiki )

1 Like

Yeah, that’s why I submit a report to use HE instead of a HEAT warhead, Gaijin nerfed it, reduced the overpressure range, considering the HEAT almost doesn’t have any Shrapnel damage, now Zuni can’t even overpressure some of the open-top targets (like SPAA), and became useless


And actually it has other warheads as I report:
https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/OuzSgqKRxmb1

No give them what ever they actually had.

You do understand what a “DIRECTIONAL” explosive is right?

Counter point, use HE if you want HE

What do you mean?

I know the HEAT is different from HE, but the current issue is that the HEAT version on ZUNI is totally useless

Rather then demanding a HEAT warhead be FICTIONALY changed to HE, use the historical weapons that are actually HE.

Does it use it IRL?

No? There were no changes to the rockets. The changes were to the vehicle modules that mistakenly caused overpressure when they were hit when they shouldn’t have.

Then that likely wouldn’t be a bug report but instead a munition addition suggestion. In that case you would have to prove that as specific vehicle was able to use that specific munition and suggest for that specific vehicle to have that munition added.

I did find it a bit odd that the ZA/ART could kill a Panther by hitting its rear running wheel, I’m sure it would have caused penetrations into the engine bay, but I doubt it would have been fatal to the entire crew… they probably wouldn’t be dancing the highland fling that night though.

Yeah, actually, they are just different versions, but universal. I’m not sure if you can review that report but I got an issue in the forum where I can’t upload it

I tried to find out the code, I remember that is due to Gaijin add “explosiveradius” to limit the overpressure range, and the range is about 0.3m

I get confused by the report if the vehicle is missing or an addition suggestion; maybe at the start Gaijin should provide different kinds of ZUNI

If there are actual HE Zunis then sure, they should be added… the VT ones… probably not… I’m already thinking of all the ways I could abuse those!
Alucard

So then you would likely need to make a suggestion for the different version then.

I cannot, only the Technical Moderators (and Community Managers) can.

There is some sort of security issues with .png images i think. .jpg should still work though.

I understand the confusion, it confuses me as well at times x)

Here is a quote from the guidelines for suggestions here on the forum:

( Rules, Guidelines & Tips For Creating Suggestions (Check Before Creating A New Suggestion!) )

1 Like

It should have the HEAT Zuni just for anti-armor targets, but HE/SAP versions are used for anti-infantry and other soft targets

Hmmm, I’m not sure if this could be considered the case: “if after being implemented, the weapon is missing from vehicles that used it in regular service, this is a matter for the [Bug Report section” The HE ZUNI is like a missing weapon from vehicles but not implemented in the game, I really don’t like to create suggestions considering the review time and votes, creating a suggestion needs more time to edit

That’d just lower the BRs of these aircraft that are currently BR’d because of the Zunis…