No, Shvaks are much better than they used to be, and are overperforming compared to IRL. The Yak-3 should be 4.7, and the Yak-3e is a 4.7 plane at 4.0 because it one less MG.
You know they can both be OP right? Plus killing a P-59 is much, much easier than killing a BI.
I recently started grinding soviet planes and shvaks are pretty decent. Granted am fighting 5.7 props and not jets but still a short burst should get the enemy if ur using tracer rounds
It technically is if we are skill going on about x vehicle is OP or under BR’d. So if hes an average pilot then his opinion can be swayed because hes less experienced than dedicated air mains which does add to the topic.
This would be the equivalent of someone saying the KV-220 is bad and should be 5.0 when their stats are only meh in said vehicle.
I find it to be a sidegrade. You either get better performance for dogfights or just not compressing. But are great imo but I am a la5fn abuser since you fight lower level enemies :)