Merkava 4 armor is long overdue to be buffed

According to a moderator, the main Report has been “connected to internal reports to track progress(?)” Well this was said 3 years ago, and where’s the progress? it’s almost 4 at this point. I just can’t withstand this absolute radio silence that gaijin is giving us, the developers don’t give a single update on it, not a single answer, no dev blog or community post to talk about it!

In the meanwhile they added more “Merkava” based tanks Like the Namer’s and guess what? Full of issues too, they added the Eitan, Full of issues as well, like please Gaijin do something!

This 1 moderator is all we got for an answer for 4 years.
It literally feels like the bug reporting community is pointless, since things just aren’t gonna get fixed, they’re just ignored.

6 Likes

Asked @Smin1080p_WT
Only got responses of “still being considered” and “no news currently” as you’ve said it’s been nearly 4 years now. We will never see the report come to the light of day. Gaijin fixed it with leopards. They don’t care

2 Likes

8 Likes

Fr though @Smin1080p_WT what progress has been made since nearly 4 years ago of asking about this other than getting the same response over and over again. “Still under consideration” just give us some kind of straightforward answer. Do the devs even care to implement the report?? Been nothing but radio silence

16 Likes

This is why people feel like subtree copy-pastes are added INSTEAD of fixes, and not “IN ADDITION TO”, like Gaijin claims.

-Where are Challenger 2’s missing hull spall liners, first-order rack size and replenishment speed and elevation speed fixes?
Nowhere to be found. Instead, Abrams.

-Where are Merkava Mk.4’s armor fixes?
Nowhere to be found. Instead, Leopard.

-Where are Type 10’s acceleration and armor fixes? (Notice I don’t even mention steering, as regenerative steering will fix that, but it’s still been broken for 5 years until it’s implemented.)
Nowhere to be found. Instead, Leopard.

-Where are Leclerc’s acceleration and upper glacis fixes?
Nowhere to be found. Instead, Leopard.


And I’m criticising this as someone who loves all of the subtree tanks, because I love all tanks equally. I just strongly feel, like many others, that they are coming in detriment to the trees’ unique designs.

Because, while Gaijin’s words say “no”, their actions say “yes”. Otherewise, these errors wouldn’t be lasting for 4+ years each.

10 Likes

I got banned couple days just because i raised my voice on this matter on general thread.

I told Smin Isreal vehicles/tree needs fixing first rather than getting sub tech trees but turns out im the bad guy for raising my voice for this matter.

10 Likes

I remember that day!

To be fair, Smin had been asking to and warning not to clog the R&R thread with bug reporting discussions (as we always inevitably do lol) and the matters were still getting out of hand a bit too much, specially with certain comments’ manners.

There were lots of “shooting the messenger” moments, considering Smin was taking a lot of flak despite being a CM and not a Dev with decision making power.

3 Likes

Whats funny is Smin wasnt the one who banned me and we already ended that discuss right before i got banned.

I just that someone decided play ‘‘hero’’ role cough cough.

4 Likes

I’ve made this report concerning Merkava!

It’s not armor, but… I guess anything that helps make it more accurate is welcome, right? ^^

https://community.gaijin.net/issues/p/warthunder/i/a0xZKhP85kN6

4 Likes

Good luck :)

2 Likes

they say SLERA works better against HEAT rather than KE, does this mean that if SLERA is introduced they will make all merkavas HEAT-resistant but remain KE weak?

2 Likes

SLERA at the end of the day its just a type of ERA. They will be always better at chemical than KE. Still it will offer some KE protection.

even without SLERA, the armor itself shouldnt be weak against KE

3 Likes

I assume it should be something like relict.

2 Likes

No, it’s not heavy ERA. It’s more anti CE, but it also provides some KE protection. Relict is heavy Explosive Reactive Armor, SLERA is Self Limiting Explosive Reactive Armor. The problem is not that the “Merkava is not the best of the best” because it’s not, the problem is that it’s armor is so comically underperforming to the point of making cold war tanks blush. It’s estimated backwards and super unrealistically, where it can get front penned by post WW2 tanks. Among other major features missing like LAHAT and spall liners that are used by everyone at this day and age, needless to say by tank which prides itself for crew protection, but since it’s not directly stated that way except in classified materials it, for some reason, is assumed to be not present. With Israel facing wars constantly it is futile to think that they’ll release any info in far future. So we’re stuck. Common sense isn’t a source.

1 Like

It is also important to mention that they did implement actual armor on LIC during dev server long ago and then removed it, so they know the issue and actively chose to ignore it.


The only time it is likely to get it’s armor modeled party is when another Russian analogovnet comes out with anti-capitalist vibranium armor with Iskander M for a gun. So don’t bother, save your nerves, this lowlife company is not worth it. You get nothing and will be happy.

15 Likes

Notoriously not Heavy ERA

We now also have another one to discuss about how wrong it has been implemented with the Eitan (P) it also has a report on it, also accepted a while ago while the Eitan still was on the Dev server, so they had everything needed to adjust it. [DEV] Israeli Eitan Prototype Armor Incorrect Still, but of course they didn’t!

This thick plate is clearly 2mm of structural still.

These also very thick plates are only 10mm!

Now let’s do the best way to compare something in war thunder, just compare it to a russian vehicle! This side plate that i could barely see the thickness without the Nvidia zoom, yeah, that’s 32mm thick, of course, it clearly is.

5 Likes

Seeing those comparisons and waiting for so many years made me lose whatever hope I had left. Even if Rank IX drops with the Merkava Mk.4M-400 MLU and the new Barak with supposedly modernized armor values, Gaijin will just copy-paste the same flawed damage model. Nothing will ever change for the Merkava/Namer/Eitan line.

2 Likes

Once the 2A7V’s armor structure is corrected to be historically accurate and added to the game, I will support having the Merkava tanks’ armor adjusted as well. However, for the sake of game balance, such changes to the Merkavas are not necessary at this time. Besides, you’ve already been given Leopards—which are even better than what Germany has.

What a wicked reasoning is that

11 Likes