Mowag Shark FL-20, a Whelled MBT

[Would you like to see this in-game?]
  • Yes
  • No
0 voters

caid’s suggestion #174

i would like to suggest a swiss armored car, one of the best of the swiss armored car ever built. the mowag Shark with FL-20

The Mowag Shark is a surprisingly large family of armored cars the was designed by Mowag in 1978 and the first prototype was built in 1981. presented as basically an enlarged version of the Mowag Piranha 8X8 with more protection. The shark was intended to be a wheeled tank and not really an IFV or APC like the piranha. more particularly for tank destroying roles but also offer a large versatility of roles due to the many turrets that could be fitted. the chassis alone weight 16 tonnes and if intended to carry a turret up to 6 tonnes gives a weight of 22 tonnes but the weight was carefully studied to give optimal agility with a 5 tonnes turret (the center of gravity would be in the exact center of the vehicle). the Shark features a high-quality suspension and high protection. but this came to a cost which was the price itself. The shark was much more expensive than the Piranha and was often capable of carrying the same turret. despite a high publicity campaign, and trials in different countries including Germany, Canada, Sweden and Switzerland, no order came for the Shark. 3 prototypes were built from 1981 to 1983 and the mass production was ready in July 1983 but this production never took place.

in this suggestion, we will focus more precisely on the Mowag Shark FL-20. this version features a brand new (at his time) FL-20 turret that was intended to replace the FL-12 and FL-15. the turret was mounted on one of the Shark in the 2nd half of 1985 and was one of the last versions created. the turret features a 105mm G1 (same as the AMX 10RC) and a coaxial 20mm. this allows the vehicle to fire APFSDS (which the FL-12 and FL-15 was unable to) which can engage some of the modern MBT that was used in that time. additionally the coaxial could also deal with the lighter armour. the turret was also equiped with night vision for both commander and gunner, laser-rangefinder, ballistic computer, and commander’s priority. all that on a rather light vehicle. it allowed the Shark to have about the same firepower as most MBT of the time (the 120mm MBT wasn’t yet very common)

Firepower
The main armament is a 105mm G1 L/44. this gun is similar to the CN-105-57 previously mounted on the FL-12, in the way it was a gun intended for light vehicles, but also features a muzzle break that allows the gun to fire APFSDS. this gun is well known as it was mounted on the AMX 10RC. the fre-rate reached 12 rounds minutes which is pretty good. the elevation is a bit limited but still acceptable with -8° to +12°. the gun is paired with an auto-loader with at least 12 rounds carried in two revolvers holding 6 rounds each. the rotation speed reaches the fair speed of 36°/sec. the main gun is paired with a 20mm F1 auto-cannon which allows the vehicle to deal with lighter targets and some heaviest with the APDS. the turret includes a 2nd generation Day/Night sight for both commander and gunner, laser-rangefinder, ballistic computer, and commander’s priority control which make this turret quite advanced compared to others.

Mobility
the Shark is powered by a General Motors Detroit Diesel 8V-71 T developing 530 hp at 2500 rpm. this was intended to give a power weight of 25 hp/ton at the weight of 21 tonnes. the shark is designed to offer a high speed on rought terrain with a top speed of 80 km/h off-road and cimb very sharp slope of 70% angle. that means that the Shark was capable of hunting his target on any terrain. the Allison automatic box model HT-750 DRD off a 5 forward speed and 1 backward. it is coupled with an auxiliary two-speed transfer box and four self-locking differentials that can be coupled, two to two or all four, pneumatically by the driver depending on the terrain conditions or driving needs. the center of gravity with a 5-tonne turret was carefully studied to be placed at exactly 1.25m from the ground right between the 2nd and 3rd axes, which is the center of the vehicle. each wheel has an independent suspension. the two middle axes aren’t steerable; their suspension is built with shock absorbers and their wheels are mounted on oscillaing arms connected to a torsion bar. the first and last are steerable and hydraulically assisted. they have suspension by wishbone, oversized helical spring, and hydraulic damper. the prototype was fitting Michelin 13.00 x 20 tubeless tires

Protection
The protection of the Shark was intended to allow it to be used fairly close to the battlefield. but retaining a good weight which was carefully studied to give a perfect balance on the vehicle. the armour was offering a protectiong against 14.5mm KPV armour piercing round or 155mm HE round at 10m on all sides. the armor was built with high-resistance armor plates and sloped on all sides to improve protection while retainign a lightweight. this makes the chassis have protection similar to the Italian Centuro B1 (without add-on armor). this makes this vehicle have protection similar to a light tank exept certain tanks like the Russian BMP have rather terrible armor. in the case of the FL-20 turret being mounted, the crew includes 3 men and 2 of them are in the turret. the turret is also built with the same specification as the chassis and also with HHRhA which makes the protection at the same level. the turret includes 8 smoke launchers who are are placed on the side but a bit on the rear.

  • This fallowing armour thickness is estimated based on the protection effiency reported and knowing the armor has been made of HHRhA
    https://i.imgur.com/DcCccAF.png

Sources
El MOWAG SHARK 8x8, un tiburón de dientes agudos - Noticias Defensa Ayer Noticia
MOWAG Shark | Secret Projects Forum

Promotional advertisement

Armoured car #30, 1995




Spoiler


Museum board

IDF Jane's


Five Lille Booklet



The Switzerland supporter discord is open to everyone

If you like to see some wacky tanks if you want to see unique aircraft, if you want to see something about a new nation that could make it to the game. Switzerland is for you

the Swiss Discord is dedicated to researching Swiss military material and support. no qualification is needed. if you want to help or have a look around, follow this link and we would be happy to welcome you

this link is valid for the first 100 persons
the 50 first to join get an automatic membership

4 Likes

I really like this tank though i wonder if it would be added in it’s full potentional form. At least I think it would be more interesting that way with stabilizer and thermals.

3 Likes

A +1 from me! We need ALL the MOWAG Sharks in the game!

2 Likes

yess

+1 this and the swiss sub tree overall is so long overdue it’s insane

1 Like

+1, but i’d like to see this also added to france’s tree, could make for a wheeled counterpart to the Marder CLOVIS (for both tech-trees, that is)

3 Likes

Cope. The vehicle was only trialed by the swiss and the most important part it was a export turret. France won’t get every single export ever that’s silly. There’s always the dutch or even french amx 13s with fl15 🤷‍♀️ still no fl20 for you guys… Should of used it

France won’t get every single export ever that’s silly.

i’m not arguing that france should get every single one

but i do think some of them are fair for france to also have, the Shark FL-20 being one of those, given that it does have significant french influence (wether you care to recognize it as such, or not).

3 Likes

No lmao that’s not how exports work 🤷‍♀️ if it had such a important value to France in some way like you said they would of at least trialed like the fl15 on their amxs but this was literally just for export. Genuinely like asking for the strv122 for Germany because mexas is a German and it’s very influential for Germany. Just a stupid point

if it had such a important value to France

i don’t know if you know this, but there’s a very big difference between “war thunder, the video-game”, and “real life arms developement and procurement”.

you do realize there are such things as “contract/mission requirements” and “budgetary constraints” that influence who would trial or buy what, but don’t really translate into War thunder, as a game? or that, even in the swiss context, the Shark FL-20 fails on those metrics by virtue of having been adopted by nobody.

…and why would it be so outlandish for france to also receive this vehicle when the entire turret is french?
that’s like saying germany shouldn’t have received the EMBT because the integration was done by Nexter/KNDS france out of the Roanne factory…
…the hull is a leopard 2’s supplied by KNDS deutschland, its reason enough for germany to get ; and its the exact same reasoning with the Shark FL-20, with its turret supplied by Fives-Cail

2 Likes

Haven’t argued otherwise.

Yet trialed by one SWITZERLAND.

Me when I use a joint program to make a point about a very not joint program…

Please check the little suggestions guidelines that shows exactly why it won’t be french.
“Tested by another nation not in game as a standalone tree” - other nation sector aka Germany your argument works if the suggestion guidelines weren’t stated already and Switzerland didn’t trial it 🤷‍♀️

Haven’t argued otherwise.

you have, because you’re openly conflating the two, when you say “if it had such a important value to France” you’re conflating : the value of the Shark FL-20 to the real life french MoD; and : the value of the Shark FL-20 to the France tech tree of War thunder

the former was minimal for reasons of inventory and budget ; the latter is much greater because of the turret involved and its capabilities.

Yet trialed by one SWITZERLAND.

and yet the turret, the entire “F” in the term “AFV”, was made by one FRANCE

Me when I use a joint program to make a point about a very not joint program…

me when i fail to see an obvious equivalency to deflect from the underlying point

the little suggestions guidelines

doesn’t mean it wouldn’t also be an acceptable addition to france, a guideline is just that “a guide”, exceptions to those guidelines can, have, and sometimes should happen

2 Likes

Because it wasn’t significant as you said. It was a export turret that didn’t gain sales. Nothing special can name 10 others.

Irrelevant when it’s trialed by a nation. Since yk France didn’t use it

It’s just not a equal example tho lmao knds Deutschland and knds France worked together for embt and it’s future products being 2022 ADT and even capint

I mean, the Clovis exists in the French tree as a Premium. So they do have a FL-20-equipped thing anyway.

As for the Shark, I think one point we might all be missing is that the Shark, as a prototype, wasn’t only trialed in Switzerland. They also trialed it in Austria, Canada, Germany, and Sweden (in different configs). So I figure there’s probably some leeway in where it gets added. As for France, the advertisements seem to call it a joint project between two private companies, so there’s probably justification for adding it there as well.

4 Likes

Because it wasn’t significant as you said. It was a export turret that didn’t gain sales.

again, you’re conflating the two, the Shark FL-20 not being adopted in real life for budget questions does not diminish what it would bring in fighting capability inside the video game.

same thing for the F-16XL or F-16AJ, same thing for the Leopard 2K or TH400, same for all the other MOWAG Sharks that also weren’t adopted

Since yk France didn’t use it

yeah, and Switzerland didn’t use it, either.

knds Deutschland and knds France worked together for embt

KNDS deutschland supplied the hull, KNDS france supplied the turret and assembled the tank in france, if we wanted to be as reductive as you are, we could say KNDS Deutschland “just supplied” the hull and thus wasn’t “really” involved (despite supplying half of the “T” in “MBT”) (and this is veering off-topic)

2 Likes

You are correct the shark itself was trialed by many nations idk where you got Austria I personally have never heard of any trials by them but 🤷‍♀️ Canada was im pretty sure just for cold weather testing could of been a trial idk lol and Sweden i also have no clue I don’t believe they ever trialed a shark either I know they did piranhas

Yea the leeway is the country who trialed in… In this case only Switzerland France just exported a turret like everyone does lmao

Are we forgetting the bundeswehr trials. That’s using it.

Again they used it for their trials to see if it would be adopted.

They did a lot more then just supplying a hull lmao like how they fully demo 'd the tank published it and many other parts. This was actually a joint program unlike again the mowag shark fl20

i genuinely don’t see where the harm in also giving it to france. the Shark FL-20 is a swiss armored car hull with an entirely french-built turret, where’s the harm in giving it to both?

(like the AMD 35 Pak, the SK-105, the DF105 or the Clovis)

3 Likes

Ah, right, turns out it was the MOWAG Trinity that was tested in Germany and was being offered to Austria.

Bofors (remember, at this time, Bofors was 100% a Swedish Company) did the initial mounting of the Trinity Turret onto the Shark and then trialed it at the Bofors Test Center in Karlskoga. All the firing-trial photos come from this location. So, by WTs logic, Sweden has a valid claim to the MOWAG Trinity

Because it’s not a french sub tree. That’s the issue plenty of french mains already try to claim swiss vehicles because xyz like your doing or like earlier with the anti air amx 13. It’s another nations sub tree ofc there’s a issue
Taking the uniqueness away from said sub tree because some angry french mains act like it’s their god given need for a export turret the french didn’t want.

Plus France already has a few German vehicles they should never of got. See amx 30 super

I stand firmly in France shouldn’t of gotten it. It should of stayed a uniquely German modification.

Girlie we’ve been over this. Joint program
And sk105 is whatever it’s a Austrian vehicle what isn’t a sub tree of anywhere so the link fits.