Sign in to follow this  
pilusss

Realistic ground battles : bug concerning the top ranking by points of the last month ?

Realistic ground battles : bug concerning the top ranking by points of the last month ?

 

Hello everyone, being interested in this ranking, I just realized that 3 players in the top 5 of this ranking of the last month were not playing or very few : less than 8 battles played by these three players over the last two months, in this game mode (random realistic ground battles), by resuming the battles played by these 3 players using the help of the Server Replays ; yet they are (these 3 players) currently ranked in the top 5 of this ranking with each of them having more than 100 battles counted (in this game mode, for the last month) to their credit ...
One of these three players even played zero realistic ground battle in 2019 and 2020, according to the Server Replays, and yet he is ranked today in the top 5 realistic ground battles of the last month !

 

How do you explain such an inconsistency?

 

 

1678929342_shot2020_03_0218_11_58.jpg.92905c2a3b064682179c1f20ccc78c1d.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hello again, everyone.

 

To try to make some progress concerning this supposed bug in the points ranking of the last month for the random realistic ground battles, the three players incriminated in the top 5 of the points ranking in the screen shot of the first message above are the players yesterday ranked N°2, N°4 and N°5 of this ranking.


The player N°4 (yesterday) of this ranking is the one who played zero random realistic ground battle in 2019 and 2020 (so far), according to the research done for this player for this battle mode, with the help of the Server Replays.

 

The most emblematic player of this supposed points ranking bug of the last month, for this battle mode, is the one who was ranked on yesterday's screen-shot (above) N°2 of the points ranking of the last month, but who was still (on February 24th, 2020) ranked first of this points ranking of the so-called last month (Nb: see the last two screen shots below).

 

Now this player, until yesterday had only achieved one random realistic ground battles, for this year 2020 (January 16, 2020), even if yesterday he achieved another battle in this game mode (March 3, 2020) in Berlin, with I believe a little more than 700 points for this last battle.

 

So how does this emblematic player, at a moment ranked first in the points ranking for the last month, by having achieved in 2020 only 2 tank battles in realistic mode (while he plays mostly in planes) can be ranked first (and currently second) for this battle mode (random realistic ground battles)?

 

I put forward the hypothesis of two different mechanisms to explain this apparent bug of points ranking in this battle mode.

 

To begin with: how does this emblematic player get more than 3,000 points on average from his more than 100 battles played in the so-called last month in this game mode (random realistic ground battles)?

 

Well, my hypothesis is that the battles counted in this game mode, for this particular player, are for the most part before the beginning of June 2019 (*), when the planes, in combined ground battles (tanks + planes) earned 3 times more points than currently. At that time, the top of the points ranking (in this random realistic ground battles game mode) reached 4,600 points, compared to just over 3,000 points for the best players today.

 

To continue: how is this emblematic player still ranked in the top 5 of this points ranking of the so-called last month for this game mode (random realistic ground battles), when he should not normally be, with only 2 realistic tank battles played in 2020 (on January 16th and March 3rd)?

 

Well, there must be a computer bug, which means that when we play a lot in another game mode than the "random realistic ground battles" mode, for example in "random realistic air battles" mode or in "random arcade air or ground battles" mode, well, at the same time, old battles from the "random realistic ground battles" game mode are then counted, especially for those three players in the top 5, with old tank battles in realistic mode prior to early June 2019, when it was much easier to get high point scores than now (as mentioned above).

 

So, what can be done to fix this supposed computer bug in the points ranking of the so-called last month, for this game mode (random realistic ground battles)?

 

Well, I propose, to start, by removing from this count used for the points actual ranking (of the so-called last month) all combined ground battles (tanks + planes) of this game mode (random realistic ground battles) played prior to June 12, 2019 (*), the date of the change in the game rules where planes were earning three times more points than now. 

(*) 

 

 

And while we are at it, delete from this count all the battles carried out in 2019 for this game mode, for the classification by points of the so-called last month, since we are currently at the beginning of March 2020, and that battles carried out in 2019 do not have nothing to do in a monthly ranking (from the so-called last month) in March 2020?

 

Here are my hypotheses and suggestions for correcting such a malfunction.

 

Best regards to all readers of these two posts. :)

 

 


 

1728914878_shot2020_02_2420_59_22.jpg.2b908e03770aa9322b2634e609f8b2f6.jpg

1123396392_shot2020_02_2421_01_12.jpg.7ffd4fd96378763bbe7f2da8544cd6c7.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

For info, from reliable source, the file has been passed on to the developers; hopefully the developers will find a solution to this bug in last month's point rating for realistic random tank battles.

 

You tell me, who cares?

 

Well, the few players who play for this points-based ranking, of course ! ;)

 

EDIT: once this computer bug is fixed, the two players of my French-speaking team *ZQS* (pilusss & pilussss) are now again keen to rub shoulders with the best regular players in realistic random tank battles, this time with the new rules of the game (applied since June 12, 2019) removing the advantages of airplanes (which now earn three times less points than before that date), and also from the EAC avenue in the realistic game mode, and which has deterred a large number of cheaters to parasitize the game, the scourge of all battles in realistic mode.

 

In screen shots below, the scores reached by the two members of my team *ZQS*, at the end of 2018 and the beginning of 2019, with the old rules of the game (before June 12, 2019), which, at that time, had favored the planes in combined ground battles.

 

 

a3 shot 2018.12.08 02.07.13.jpg

b3 shot 2019.02.08 16.44.20.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Good morning, everyone.

 

Despite the transmission of the file to the game's developers, the problem of the computer bug concerning the monthly ranking by points in the realistic random tank battles game mode is still not solved, as of today.

 

See the two screen shots (below) taken today concerning in particular the player ranked this day first of this monthly ranking by points (of the so-called last month) in this game mode (realistic random tank battles), while this player has played only 3 realistic tank battles in 2020 (on January 16, March 3 and March 5, 2020 ...).

 

 

shot 2020.03.12 09.09.03.jpg

 

shot 2020.03.12.jpg

 

EDIT (12.03.20 - 21 h 30):

 

Tonight (at 9 pm), the player still ranked N°1 this morning in the points ranking for realistic random tank battles is now ranked only N°2 (see the screen shot below of the ranking taken just this evening).

 

Very interesting inconsistency to note: because according to the classification between the two screen shots taken this morning (above) and the screen shot taken this evening (below), the player in question would have passed, between this morning and this evening, from 143 battles counted over the last month (this morning), to 158 battles counted over the last month (this evening): that is to say 15 new tank battles in the game mode realistic random tank battles counted in addition between this morning and this evening ....

 

However, there's a big snag, this player has always played only 3 tank battles in this game mode in 2020 (on January 16, March 3 and March 5, 2020) according to this player's Server Replay, re-checked tonight at 9pm (just as indicated in the screen shot taken this morning, above).

 

So the question is: where did these 15 new random realistic tank battles come from, additionally counted this very day, when this player has played zero new random realistic tank battles since March 5, 2020, according to this player's Server Replay, for this battle mode ?????

 

 

shot 2020.03.12 21.12.11.jpg

 

shot 2020.03.12.jpg

Edited by pilussss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

The problem of the computer bug concerning the monthly ranking by points in the realistic random tank battles game mode is still not solved, as of today.

 

At this day (19 march 2020), 2 players are ranked in the top 3 of the so-called last month  ranking by points, in the realistic random tank battles game mode and have played, in this game mode, only 10 and 11 battles (respectively) since August 2019 !!!  (by resuming the battles played by these 2 players using the help of the Server Replays, this day).

 

 

 

 

shot 2020.03.19 13.26.49.jpg

 

shot 2020.03.19 13.27.02.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

The problem of the computer bug concerning the monthly ranking by points in the realistic random tank battles game mode is still not solved, as of today. 
(Note: problem reported, from the beginning of November 2019, to one of the game managers).

 

To date (March 25, 2020), the top two players in the overall points-based ranking of the so-called last month, in the game mode of realistic random tank battles, have only played, in this game mode, 12 and 12 battles (respectively), since the beginning of the year 2020 (compared to 174 and 171 battles, respectively, counted, over the last month, in this game mode) ; by taking over the battles played by these 2 players using the server replays, today.

 

 

shot 2020.03.25 13.12.03.jpg

shot 2020.03.25 13.12.07.jpg

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

The problem of the computer bug concerning the monthly ranking by points in the realistic random tank battles game mode is still not solved, as of today.

 

At this day (30 march 2020), 2 players (*) are ranked in the top 3 of the so-called last month  ranking by points, in the realistic random tank battles game mode and have played, in this game mode, only 20 and 13 battles (respectively) since August 2019 !!!  (by resuming the battles played by these 2 players using the help of the Server Replays, this day).
(*) Today N°2 and 3 at the top 3 of this ranking. Se the screenshot below.

 

If the developers of this game don't know how to solve this points ranking bug in this battle mode (random realistic tanks battle); a bug reported to the authorities at the beginning of November 2019..., well, I propose the pure and simple deletion of this points ranking, in this game mode, which now doesn't mean anything anymore because of this bug that has been demonstrated many times (Nb: re-read my previous posts).

 

I even propose to keep only the ranking of the player's position (in %) in his team (podium ranking). 

 

Ranking of the position in the team (podium), which currently imho reflects much better the skill and merits of a player for a ranking in each battle played (if he regularly finishes first or second in his team, for example) rather than the number of points obtained in each battle (distorted for some players currently playing very little in this game mode, and taking advantage of the high points obtained before the change of the game rules, June 12, 2019, as indicated many times in my previous posts) ; points which, moreover, are easier to obtain in low BR battles than high BR battles. 

 

This would be fairer for all players.

 

What do you think about it?

 

 

shot 2020.03.30 12.11.38.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
13 hours ago, Skorbutas said:

God, I hope you won't stop! Someone of Gaijin finally will answer!...maybe...after three year...

 

Thank you for your encouragement. :)

PS: to prove my point (on how long ago this bug was reported) here is a copy-paste of my PM sent to a game manager on November 5th, 2019.
Message written in french : you can of course use google translate for non french speakers.

 

Bonjour XXXX

 

Ce n'est pas à proprement parler une triche, mais plutôt une anomalie (ou un bug informatique ?) exploité par un joueur pour se maintenir artificiellement à la tête du classement mensuel (du mois dernier) pour les batailles réalistes de chars, pour le classement par points du dernier mois (le classement étoile le plus à droite du tableau du classement).

 

Le premier du classement par points (classement étoile), pour les batailles réalistes de chars, pour le classement mensuel (du mois dernier) est actuellement Senia5 avec 3.232 points et 225 batailles de chars à son compteur pour le dernier mois (Nb : il faut avoir à son actif plus de 100 batailles de chars le dernier mois pour être classé ; les anciennes batailles de chars, plus anciennes que 30 jours, sont normalement décomptées).

 

Or Senia5 ne joue pratiquement plus aux chars en batailles réalistes depuis 5 mois (depuis mai 2019) et il reste malgré cela pourtant toujours classé premier pour ce classement par points pour les batailles de chars réalistes avec toujours 225 batailles de chars réalistes à son actif (pour le dernier mois).

Or, d'après une recherche faite sur le server replay des batailles réalistes de chars concernant ce joueur,  Senia 5 a fait zéro batailles réalistes de chars en Novembre 2019; seulement 4 batailles de chars réalistes en Octobre 2019; 3 batailles de chars réalistes en septembre 2019; 1 seule bataille de char réaliste en août 2019; zéro batailles de chars réalistes en juillet 2019; et zéro batailles de chars réalistes en juin 2019, et malgré cela, il reste toujours classé premier en batailles de chars réalistes, pour le dernier mois, depuis 5 mois !, avec actuellement toujours 225 batailles de chars à son actif, sans qu'elles soient décomptées !

S'agit-il d'un bug informatique ?

D'un autre côté, très curieusement, Senia 5 ne fait plus que des parties d'avions (assez nombreuses) depuis le mois de Juin 2019 (à l'exceptions des très rares parties de chars énumérées ci-dessus: 8 batailles de chars jouées, seulement, en 5 mois !!!).

 

Est-ce que cette façon très particulière de jouer est bien normale (et acceptable) ? : ne faire actuellement que des parties d'avions (batailles réalistes d'avions) pour permettre (apparemment) de maintenir artificiellement un score élevé en points (étoiles) mais pour les batailles réalistes de chars (qui par cet artifice ne seraient pas décomptées ?), sans quasiment plus jouer aux chars depuis 5 mois (8 batailles de chars jouées en 5 mois !), ce qui serait une manière injuste de maintenir un score élevé pour le classement mensuel de chars (par points) sans remettre en question actuellement (chaque mois, depuis 5 mois !) son score gagné à l'époque (en mai 2019) où l'on pouvait gagner beaucoup plus de points au classement des batailles réalistes combinées chars + avions, car les avions rapportaient à cette époque beaucoup plus de points (3 x plus) que les chars, ce qui n'est plus le cas actuellement.

 

Vous pouvez vérifier mes dires en examinant les statistique de Senia 5 sur les replays server, en cochant les cases : batailles réalistes, batailles aléatoires et chars, pour voir le très peu de parties en chars jouées  par ce joueur ces 5 derniers mois, et le "bug informatique" suspecté de ne pas décompter les batailles de chars depuis 5 mois (en jouant que les avions dans la même période) en maintenant ainsi un score artificiellement élevé, comme indiqué ci-dessus;

L'exploitation d'une faille du système?

 

Bien cordialement.

 

Eric de la team ZQS (pilusss et pilussss)

 

PS: pour comparaison pilusss (mon joueur) ne joue plus à War Thunder depuis le 23 juillet dernier, et toutes ses batailles de chars précédentes ont été décomptées (actuellement zéro batailles de chars à mon actif au classement mensuel de char ; je ne suis plus classé).

(Nb : pilusss rejouera à WT dés que l'EAC sera effectif, mais c'est une autre histoire ; bientôt, je l'espère ...) "

medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

The problem of the computer bug concerning the monthly ranking by points in the realistic random tank battles game mode is still not solved, as of today.

 

As of today (April 3, 2020), the player currently ranked #2 in the top 3 of the points ranking  of the so-called last month, in the realistic game mode of random tank battles, has played zero new tank battles (in this game mode) since March 23, 2020 (by resuming  the battles played by thise player using the server replays, today).

 

However, this same player, between March 30, 2020 and April 3, 2020 has gone from 168 tank battles (counted over the last month in this game mode, on March 30), to today (April 3) 221 tank battles, in this same game mode: that is 53 new tank battles in the realistic random tank battle mode, since March 30, 2020 (since 3 days), while the player has not played any new realistic random tank battles since March 23, 2020 (since 10 days) !!!

 

Where do these 53 new tank battles in random realistic mode come from, counted in addition, for this player, since 3 days, while the player has not played in this battle mode since 10 days ago?????

 

 

shot 2020.03.30 12.11.38.jpg

Screen shot dated 3 days ago (March 30, 2020)

 

shot 2020.04.03 08.43.39.jpg

Screen shot dated today (April 3, 2020)

Edited by pilussss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 30/03/2020 at 19:34, Skorbutas said:

God, I hope you won't stop! Someone of Gaijin finally will answer!...maybe...after three year...

 

Gaijin's silence is deafening!

 

Now 5 months since the bug was reported, and still no answer to this problem ...

medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

In the top 16 of the ranking by points of the random realistic tank battles from the so-called last month, viewed today (see the screen shot below dated Tuesday, April 7, 2020), these three players have nothing to do in this monthly ranking by points, for this tank battle mode !

 

- Senia5, with only 17 random realistic tank battles played since January 1, 2020, in this battle mode.  (*)
- bozman678, with only 14 random realistic tank battles played since January 1, 2020, in this battle mode. (*)
- yzc677 with only 5 random realistic tank battles played since January 1, 2020, in this battle mode. (*)

 

Thank you Gaijin if you could downgrade them quickly for more equity compared to the other players ...

 

(*) according to the replay server data consulted today (Tuesday 7 April 2020).

 

 

shot 2020.04.07 21.17.48.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
On 31/03/2020 at 08:47, pilusss said:

 

Thank you for your encouragement. :)

PS: to prove my point (on how long ago this bug was reported) here is a copy-paste of my PM sent to a game manager on November 5th, 2019.
Message written in french : you can of course use google translate for non french speakers.

 

Bonjour XXXX

 

Ce n'est pas à proprement parler une triche, mais plutôt une anomalie (ou un bug informatique ?) exploité par un joueur pour se maintenir artificiellement à la tête du classement mensuel (du mois dernier) pour les batailles réalistes de chars, pour le classement par points du dernier mois (le classement étoile le plus à droite du tableau du classement).

 

Le premier du classement par points (classement étoile), pour les batailles réalistes de chars, pour le classement mensuel (du mois dernier) est actuellement Senia5 avec 3.232 points et 225 batailles de chars à son compteur pour le dernier mois (Nb : il faut avoir à son actif plus de 100 batailles de chars le dernier mois pour être classé ; les anciennes batailles de chars, plus anciennes que 30 jours, sont normalement décomptées).

 

Or Senia5 ne joue pratiquement plus aux chars en batailles réalistes depuis 5 mois (depuis mai 2019) et il reste malgré cela pourtant toujours classé premier pour ce classement par points pour les batailles de chars réalistes avec toujours 225 batailles de chars réalistes à son actif (pour le dernier mois).

Or, d'après une recherche faite sur le server replay des batailles réalistes de chars concernant ce joueur,  Senia 5 a fait zéro batailles réalistes de chars en Novembre 2019; seulement 4 batailles de chars réalistes en Octobre 2019; 3 batailles de chars réalistes en septembre 2019; 1 seule bataille de char réaliste en août 2019; zéro batailles de chars réalistes en juillet 2019; et zéro batailles de chars réalistes en juin 2019, et malgré cela, il reste toujours classé premier en batailles de chars réalistes, pour le dernier mois, depuis 5 mois !, avec actuellement toujours 225 batailles de chars à son actif, sans qu'elles soient décomptées !

S'agit-il d'un bug informatique ?

D'un autre côté, très curieusement, Senia5 ne fait plus que des parties d'avions (assez nombreuses) depuis le mois de Juin 2019 (à l'exceptions des très rares parties de chars énumérées ci-dessus: 8 batailles de chars jouées, seulement, en 5 mois !!!).

 

Est-ce que cette façon très particulière de jouer est bien normale (et acceptable) ? : ne faire actuellement que des parties d'avions (batailles réalistes d'avions) pour permettre (apparemment) de maintenir artificiellement un score élevé en points (étoiles) mais pour les batailles réalistes de chars (qui par cet artifice ne seraient pas décomptées ?), sans quasiment plus jouer aux chars depuis 5 mois (8 batailles de chars jouées en 5 mois !), ce qui serait une manière injuste de maintenir un score élevé pour le classement mensuel de chars (par points) sans remettre en question actuellement (chaque mois, depuis 5 mois !) son score gagné à l'époque (en mai 2019) où l'on pouvait gagner beaucoup plus de points au classement des batailles réalistes combinées chars + avions, car les avions rapportaient à cette époque beaucoup plus de points (3 x plus) que les chars, ce qui n'est plus le cas actuellement.

 

Vous pouvez vérifier mes dires en examinant les statistique de Senia 5 sur les replays server, en cochant les cases : batailles réalistes, batailles aléatoires et chars, pour voir le très peu de parties en chars jouées  par ce joueur ces 5 derniers mois, et le "bug informatique" suspecté de ne pas décompter les batailles de chars depuis 5 mois (en jouant que les avions dans la même période) en maintenant ainsi un score artificiellement élevé, comme indiqué ci-dessus;

L'exploitation d'une faille du système?

 

Bien cordialement.

 

Eric de la team ZQS (pilusss et pilussss)

 

PS: pour comparaison pilusss (mon joueur) ne joue plus à War Thunder depuis le 23 juillet dernier, et toutes ses batailles de chars précédentes ont été décomptées (actuellement zéro batailles de chars à mon actif au classement mensuel de char ; je ne suis plus classé).

(Nb : pilusss rejouera à WT dés que l'EAC sera effectif, mais c'est une autre histoire ; bientôt, je l'espère ...) "

 

Good morning, everyone.

 

A question to the community, but also to the administrators of Gaijin and the moderators of this forum.

 

In spite of the strict rules of the EULA War Thunder game, is it acceptable that a player voluntarily exploits a flaw in the War Thunder game system (the suspected bug mentioned and proven many times in this thread) in order to artificially maintain himself at the top of the ranking by points for random realistic tank battles?

 

 Wouldn't this be a form of disguised cheating, deliberate and disloyal to other players, which could possibly (or even should) be sanctioned.

 

The player pilusss has already mentioned this subject in his PM written in French, to one of the people in charge of the game, November 5, 2019, 5 months ago now!

 

For more understanding for the community, I made an automatic translation of this message (PM) in French via DeepL translator: see the translation, below, and the original message in French (quote above).

 

Hello XXXX

 

This is not strictly speaking a cheat, but rather an anomaly (or a computer bug?) exploited by a player to artificially keep himself at the top of the monthly ranking (of last month) for realistic tank battles, for the points ranking of the last month (the rightmost star ranking of the leaderboard).

 

The first in the points ranking (star ranking), for realistic tank battles, for the monthly ranking (of last month) is currently Senia5 with 3,232 points and 225 tank battles for the last month (Nb: you must have more than 100 tank battles in the last month to be ranked; old tank battles, older than 30 days, are normally counted down).

 

However, Senia5 has hardly played any realistic tank battles for 5 months (since May 2019) and despite this, it is still ranked first for this ranking by points for realistic tank battles with 225 realistic tank battles to its credit (for the last month).

However, according to a search on the replay server of realistic tank battles for this player, Senia5 had zero realistic tank battles in November 2019; only 4 realistic tank battles in October 2019; 3 realistic tank battles in September 2019; only 1 realistic tank battle in August 2019; zero realistic tank battles in July 2019; and zero realistic tank battles in June 2019, and despite that, he still ranked first in realistic tank battles, for the last 5 months! With currently still 225 tank battles to his credit, without being counted!

Is it a computer bug?

 

On the other hand, curiously enough, Senia5 is only playing airplane games (quite numerous) since June 2019 (except for the very rare tank games listed above: 8 tank battles played, only, in 5 months !!!).

 

Is this very particular way of playing normal (and acceptable)? The only way to play is to play only airplane games (realistic airplane battles) to allow (apparently) to keep an artificially high score in points (stars), but for the realistic tank battles (which by this artifice would not be counted?), without almost no more tank games since 5 months (8 tank battles played in 5 months!). ), which would be an unfair way to maintain a high score for the monthly tank ranking (by points) without questioning currently (every month, for the last 5 months!) its score earned at the time (in May 2019) when one could earn many more points in the ranking of realistic battles combined tanks + airplanes, because airplanes brought back at that time many more points (3 x more) than tanks, which is no longer the case today.

 

You can verify this by looking at the Senia5 statistics on the replays server, by checking the boxes: realistic battles, random battles and tanks, to see the very few tank games played by this player in the last 5 months, and the suspected "computer bug" of not counting the tank battles in the last 5 months (playing only planes in the same period), thus maintaining an artificially high score, as indicated above;

Exploiting a system flaw?

 

With kind regards.

 

Eric from team *ZQS* (pilusss and pilussss)


PS: for comparison: pilusss (my player) hasn't played War Thunder since July 23rd, and all his previous tank battles have been counted down (currently I have zero tank battles in the monthly tank ranking; I'm no longer ranked).  "

 

Translated with www.DeepL.com/Translator (free version)

 

 

So, to be concrete and limit ourselves to the facts: does the Senia5 player voluntarily exploit the flaw in the system mentioned (the suspected computer bug) for 10 months now !!! to maintain himself artificially in the top 3 of the points ranking for realistic random tank battles?

 

The facts:

 

Before the game rule change dated June 12, 2019 (*), ending the considerable advantage of planes in combined tank+plane battles (where before this date, planes earned 3 times more points per kill than tanks, and where battle scores averaged up to 4800 points per 100 battles; compared to the current average of about 3000 points per 100 battles); well, prior to that fateful date of June 12, 2020, the Senia5 player played (according to Server replay data accessed over the past year):


- more than 134 realistic random tank battles in March 2019.
- 247 realistic random tank battles in April 2019
- 68 realistic random tank battles in May 2019

 

After that fateful date of June 12, 2019 (*) (date of the change in the rules of the game), Senia5 played in the same realistic random tank battle mode:


- zero realistic random tank battles in June 2019 (month of the change in the rules of the game).
- zero realistic random tank battles in July 2019.
- 1 realistic random tank battle in August 2019.
- 2 realistic random tank battles in September 2019.
- 4 realistic random tank battles in October 2019.
- 2 realistic random tank battles in November 2019.
- zero realistic random tank battles in December 2019.
- 1 realistic random tank battle in January 2020.

- zero realistic random tank battles in February 2020.
- 11 realistic random tank battles in March 2020.
- 5 realistic random tank battles in April 2020 (as of April 9th).

 

However, it should be pointed out, and it is reasonable to think that player Senia5 was informed, this player is ranked in the top 16 (and even top 3) of the points ranking for random realistic tank battles since July 2019 (since 9 months now ...).

 

So, why has Senia5 stopped playing realistic random tank battles (or very few) since June 2019, the very date of the change of the game rules for this battle mode???? 


Simple coincidence or voluntary exploitation of a system flaw (computer bug) to artificially maintain itself at the top of this ranking?

 

It's up to you to judge ...

 

 

 

(*) 

Stona

  • Чебурашка
  •  
  • Stona
  • Community Manager
  •  53,735
  • 14,743 posts
  • Gender:Male
  • Location:Poland

Maintenance%20(1).jpg

  • Mission points, which players receive for active actions in Combined Battles while flying aircraft now correspond to the earnings whilst playing ground or fleet vehicles depending on the selected game mode.

 

 

Edited by pilussss

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Hi all.

 

The two players pilusss & pilussss of my french-speaking team *ZQS* are very proud to be back in the top 16 of the realistic random tank battles ranking of the last month, both for the "podium" ranking : for the position in the team (with a score of 92 % for these two players) (note: ranking not bugged) and for the "star" ranking : ranking by points (ranking unfortunately currently bugged, therefore not valid for all), with respectively a score of 2.800 points and 2.749 points, out of more than 100 random realistic tank battles actually played these last 30 days. Against, for example and for comparison, only 26 random realistic tank battles actually played by Senia5, since June 2019 !!! (for 10 months now); player yet ranked in this same top 16, of this game mode, for the so-called last month ....

 ... ... and who is quoted as an example, because he his, for me, the most emblematic player of this dysfunction (bug) of the points ranking, in this game mode, and this for 10 months now (as shown by several of my previous posts ...).

 

 

Note: These two screenshots (below) are dated this morning (Friday, April 10, 2020, am), with a screenshot of the "podium" ranking (position in the team, in %) and a screenshot of the "star" ranking (ranking by points) for the realistic random tank battles of the so-called last month.

 

shot 2020.04.10 07.28.58.jpg

 

shot 2020.04.10 07.29.21.jpg

 

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

Morning, everyone.

 

For the developpers.

 

How to find out in the top 16 of the current points ranking, for the realistic random tank battles, the players currently "benefiting" from this bug? (*)

 

(*) I.e. the players currently ranked in this monthly ranking by points (for this game mode), having played more than 100 battles in the month (according to this ranking), whereas the examination of the server replays of the games actually played by these same players, in this game mode, for the last month, actually shows a number of battles much lower than 100 battles; therefore these players should not normally be ranked for this game mode ...

 

Well, you just have to look in the same table of the points ranking over the last month their current position in the team in % (podium ranking).
 If this "podium" ranking shows a position in the team < 85%, then these players most probably benefit from this bug ; you can check it by looking at the number of battles actually played over the last month, in this game mode, by these players, using the server replays.

 

 

shot 2020.04.15 08.41.24.jpg

 

shot 2020.04.15 08.41.45.jpg

Edited by pilusss
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
19 minutes ago, cpt_nosh said:

Are you just promoting yourself in this thread?

 

I'm just trying to fix a bug in the ranking by points of the last month, for realistic battles of random tanks, which has been reported since the beginning of November 2019 (initially in pm); the link for this thread is currently being followed by the game developers (the info was sent to the game developpers by one of the game managers).

 

If you play for the points ranking (and for the position in the team) in this game mode, you would be directly concerned by this bug (and this thread which I try to feed with facts) ...

 

I was not playing and was not ranked in November 2019; it is not my fault if I am currently ranked with more than 100 fights actually played in the last 30 days (the last month), in this game mode! ;)

  • Upvote 2
medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

What purpose does the ranking have in effect? Also if you're concerned about a bug, why not make a bug report like it's intended sintead of going to the Ground RB forum with it?

medal medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 minutes ago, cpt_nosh said:

What purpose does the ranking have in effect? Also if you're concerned about a bug, why not make a bug report like it's intended sintead of going to the Ground RB forum with it?

 

This thread also concerns the few other players (than me) who play for this ranking.

 

What is a ranking for?

 

Maybe to take up a challenge! ;)

medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, pilusss said:

 

This thread also concerns the few other players (than me) who play for this ranking.

 

What is a ranking for?

 

Maybe to take up a challenge! ;)

 

It's meaningless. Nobody is standing in line to pat you on the back for running up high scores against new players. How about you focus on playing well at a more reasonable battle rating for your experience level instead of spamming the forum with "How great you are"?

 

 

Screenshot_20200415-093520.thumb.png.02b

 

Screenshot_20200415-094239.thumb.png.f89

 

Edited by Mudhorn
Added image
medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
1 hour ago, Mudhorn said:

 

It's meaningless. Nobody is standing in line to pat you on the back for running up high scores against new players. How about you focus on playing well at a more reasonable battle rating for your experience level instead of spamming the forum with "How great you are"?

 

 

Screenshot_20200415-093520.thumb.png.02b

 

Screenshot_20200415-094239.thumb.png.f89

 

 

It's far from meaningless (at least for me).

 

Since you mention it, my challenge is to gather the two members of my French-speaking team in the top 16 of this ranking, both for points and especially for the position in the team ("podium" ranking not bugged, contrary to the current ranking by points).

I play in BR 2.3 level (as incidentally  the first of this ranking, the excelent player cekseh), but contrary to him, I use planes (which bring almost nothing for the points won compared to the old rules of the game).
Three times out of four, I am confronted with level BR 3.0 and 3.3 tanks and planes, and it's not an easy task!
And there is also an incredible amount of generals, colonels and captains playing in level BR 2.3 to 3.3!
It's a thrilling level of play for anyone who knows how to fly a tank and aircraft correctly, and also knows how to manage their reappearance points correctly.

 

But all this is a bit out of topic ; what is your expertise on the bug mentioned in this thread and what is your proposed solution to fix it?

 

medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
5 hours ago, pilusss said:

what is your proposed solution to fix it?

 

 

My proposed solution is to remove it, since it is apparently encouraging trash behavior like you playing thousands of missions in entry-tier vehicles in order to pad your stats and feel better about yourself via this ranking system.

medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
20 minutes ago, Mudhorn said:

 

My proposed solution is to remove it, since it is apparently encouraging trash behavior like you playing thousands of missions in entry-tier vehicles in order to pad your stats and feel better about yourself via this ranking system.

 

My proposal is the same as yours (remove the points ranking, since it's bugged), so not for the same reasons as yours! :D

medal medal medal medal

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Sign in to follow this  

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    No registered users viewing this page.